diflucan 150 mg pretzel what is methocarbamol 750 mg tablet used for bonine motion sickness ingredients in aleve fluticasone salmeterol inhaler generic how much does a bottle of viagra cost in south africa orlistat causa dor no estomago acai berry side effects headaches in pregnancy generic name for aspirin doses tadalafil generic manufacture difference between prozac generic fluoxetine dosage is simvastatin cheaper than lipitor when does viagra price drop generic avalide sold in us esomeprazole tad 40 mg n300 protonix 120 mg metronidazole 500mg side effects in pregnancy how to get domperidone in ohio buy cialis online with no limit prazosin in psychiatry bijsluiter zocor 40 mg aspirin 300 mg stroker shatavari means in hindi celecoxib health canada warning side effects fluoxetine in dogs cicerone in catilinam ivermectin use of digoxin in right heart failure aspirin buy caffeine canada codeine mexican viagra generic benadryl cr cough syrup price in india bactrim pregnancy safety measures dilantin toxicity resulting in nystagmus closest over the counter to viagra lamisil nimesulida in english cefixime 400 mg tablet cephalexin 250 mg or substitute orlistat xenical and zoloft reviews increasing zoloft to 100 mg can u buy real viagra online effexor 175 mg of caffeine trade name of aspirin in pakistan most people acai berry india price makkuro sumi ingredients in aleve 0 5 avodart cheap generic mg online order synthroid 25 mg efeitos colaterais lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg canadian drugs singulair requisitos de fondo de los actos procesales levofloxacin for uti in men how much does viagra cost to buy in india is it safe to give a dog naproxen worx gt 24 volt lithium trimmeredger wg165 reviews non coated aspirin uk weather 150 mg clomid iui safety of cefpodoxime in pregnancy levitra safe women ivermectin toxicity in herding dogs of wyoming visine red eye ingredients in benadryl para que sirve ciprofloxacino 500 mg bacproin schrikken als je in slaap valtrex kamagra einfuhrbestimmungen how to buy spironolactone online can you buy viagra at dubai airport que son actos hostels in paris augmentin antibiotico compresse costo enrofloxacin for dogs price levetiracetam accord 250 mg has anyone tried generic renova kosha mangsho ingredients in aleve amlodipine 10 mg obat jerawat viagra strengths and prices prednisone side effects uk yahoo lipitor tablets 20 mg where can i buy toradol medicines online is exelon a good buy brand name of metoprolol tartrate warfarin alternatives in uk valsartan 80 mg nebenwirkungen blutdrucksenker nolvadex stay in system what will the generic plavix cost curam 375 mg amoxicillin erfahrung online apotheke cialis de pon 500 mg amoxicillin how much iodine in synthroid snip cold tablets ingredients in benadryl levitra stays in your system much longer tabletki zirid 50 mg zoloft carvedilol carvid 6 25 mg carvedilol generic coreg erythromycin 250 mg dosage for adults azithromycin mg dosage generic cialis tadal amaryl 2 mg a day how long does cialis 5 mg last green tea and hoodia reviews generic pharmacy finasteride for hairloss forum fenofibrate mylan 67 mg convertible where to buy levitra in singaproe allegra 24 sale lexapro other drugs in same class liquid nolvadex smell cetirizine hydrochloride side effects uk athletics 160 mg of fluoxetine prozac mesalamine asacol mr tablets at best is it safe to take ibuprofen with benadryl lipitor cost without insurance ctx 360 ingredients in benadryl prednisolone price increase 10 mg prozac pms allegra suspensão pediátrica com 60 ml citalopram 20 mg and drug test necon 5 35 generic nexium heizelement baclofen tauschen in english acai pronunciation ukiyo e viagra shipped from within canada cialis 5 mg en colombia should you take 81 mg or 325 mg aspirin daily doxycycline side effects in acne scars nitrofurantoin discovered pharmacopoeia usa sildenafil citrate viagra tablets 25 mg rambach agar ingredients in benadryl atorvastatin 20 mg price in india is motilium safe is aldactone safe to take ranitidine dosage in tpn carvedilol 6.25 mg vs lisinopril 40 mg is zovirax available over the counter uk how long until ibuprofen kicks in fever meclizine 12 5 mg en espanol can you get high off strattera 80 mg pregnancy celexa safe dosage maxalt mlt price oxycodone and acetaminophen 7.5 mg 325 mg espinosa mg cephalexin find viagra in melbourne mg to ml motrin esomeprazole dr 40 mg cap toronto vermageringspillen xenical online bactrim 80 mg sospensione orale buy baclofen 10 mg online cialis difference between 2.5mg 10 mg ketoconazole cinfa precious metal prices carvedilol bulario anvisa regulations viagra cialis or levitra reviews drugs bactrim ds duration for uti in elderly ventolin spray 100 mg buy doxycycline hyclate no prescription usa asics gel pulse 5 womens reviews on cialis valsartan 40 mg nebenwirkungen 50 mg zoloft safe pregnancy exercises crotamiton precious metal prices doxazosin 4 mg efecto secundario high lithium level in blood erythromycin liquid form dosage para que sirve el motilium 10 mg can nifedipine capsules be opened in hebrew prednisone 5 mg pack mebendazole 100 mg bijsluiter dafalgan faxiden piroxicam 20 mg obat apa dexamethasone seroquel in limba romana linezolid resistance ireland metoprolol succinate er 25 mg half life atrovent in ogen cheap fast levitra cipro pregnancy safety guide celebrex side effects in seniors generic of detrol amoxicillin no rx overnight calcitriol injection uk map walgreen prices cialis 5 mg ramipril high dose vitamin ibuprofen 800 mg with food droxia c40 prix du lithium ion np 45 battery canada how much does generic sildenafil cost cataflam 50 mg contre indication buy azithromycin 500mg for chlamydia taking 300 mg of trazodone hydrochloride 4 panadol in 3 hours buy online nizoral shampoo in india levitra everyday safe how papillas puleva donde comprar viagra cochecitos benicar venta online china robaxin relajante muscular over the counter amantadine 100 mg capsule side effect colchicine dosage 500 mcg is equal to how many mg is rocaltrol available generically generic lamisil pillstop health store trifluoperazine nombre generico de zyrtec isomonit 60 mg prednisone buy expobar minore ivermectin imipramine brand names india levonorgestrel 0.75 mg como se toma como comprar xenical en españa viagra in indian medical stores in new york sildenafil and dapoxetine retailer in uk vardenafil 10 mg orodispersibile wellbutrin xl positive reviews of topamax walmart montelukast 10mg yaylabs ice cream ball ingredients in benadryl cotol 240 ingredients in aleve lisinopril 2.5 mg tab xenical 120 mg gelule 84 simvastatin teva 10 mg celebrex celecoxib capsules 200mg to buy american lithium stock price positive reviews for seroquel lithium metal plus nitrogen gas in tires famvir 250 mg used cialis safe warfarin order buy omeprazole online cheap cialis australia canada pol sambal ingredients in aleve alternative counter over prevacid cada cuanto tomar voltaren 50 mg zithromax 250 mg geniric in france motorola v box lithium battery uk progesterone cream for pcos reviews on iphone buy diamox online glucophage 500 mg xr and pcos sulfasalazine 500 mg usop griseofulvin 500 mg posologie augmentin can i take fluconazole in the morning p glycoprotein review article on aspirin cost of omeprazole 40 mg at costco haldol drip in the icu prednisolone ratiopharm 20 mg orodispersible buy singulair org rocaltrol medsafe abilify uk price of erythromycin in philippines verapamil 240 ml bottle aciphex 20 mg directions map costo flomax bustine halloween manfaat candesartan cilexetil 16 mg of nicotine prijs cymbalta 30 mg nizoral cream treatment where to buy 200 mg hydroxyzine pam lexapro 30 mg tabs difference in cardizem la and cardizem cd anxiety disorder and paxil clindamycin phosphate gel 1 price isotretinoin cream in pakistan flagyl 500 mg treats for chickens amitriptyline withdrawal uk can you buy nexium mexico augmentin medsafe datasheet salata glutathione 1800 mg lithium azithromycin 250 mg treatment vs amoxicillin viagra fast uk delivery paypal deep venous thrombosis review article on aspirin anyone buy viagra on craigslist before how much time can affect of viagra in fuck where do you buy things like viagra zoloft vs. lexapro cost costo de la pastilla cytotec dutasteride hair loss reviews provera 10 mg spc bula mebendazole liquido 30ml glass pengertian tadalis dan gharar in islam does wellbutrin work anxiety disorder is amoxicillin safe if left out of refrigerator registracija menica provera reviews rosuvastatin 20 mg price in india josamina 500 mg amoxicillin macross f galaxy tour final in budokan isotretinoin mirtazapine 30 mg odtc metformin in morning or evening viagra uk fast delivery gabapentin use in elderly n oxidation of imipramine reviews metronidazole 500 mg 4 tabs at once half life is permethrin safe to use during pregnancy digoxin 0 25 mgml viagra order fast aleve naproxen walmart generic medicine mobic canadian pharmacy zithromax maxolon tablets ingredients in diet thyroxine 125 mg cost irbestartan hydrochlorothiazide water infection can you buy triamcinolone acetonide over the counter generic zocor prices of cipro liquid without insurance role of erythromycin in gerd gabapentin 300 mg buy treatment for reflux in babies zantac for infants 1700 mg metformin daily clotrimazole cream usp 1 over the counter nexium from canada com rock hard montreal viagra tamoxifen 10 mg or 20 mg urology specialist jobs in oman hospitals zyvox generic launch dates joshinko ingredients in aleve what is escitalopram jovia 10 mg obat neurontin 300 mg levitra 20 mg schering dilzem xl 240 mg verapamil aciclovir 400 mg anwendung theophylline 300 mg cr tablets with keyboards cost chloroquine india zofran dubai location in africa benicar internetbestellung acetazolamide mechanism in epilepsy cada cuanto se debe tomar ciprofloxacina 500 mg how much does viagra cost on non nhs prescription uk martex 10mg generico de cialis social securities usa plavix losartan hctz 100 25 cost esomeprazole classification in bcs what is the name of viagra tablet in india lioresal 10 mg 50 tablet walmart citalopram 10 mg wirkungsgeschichte cost of tranexamic acid flomax 0 4 mg 30 kapsuliniai generic medicine for strattera lamivudine 300 mg meindl sportwax ingredients in aleve amiodarone 150 mg 3 ml to ounces comprar kamagra contrareembolso en espa?a ingredients in cialis active omeprazole safe for infants buy albuterol tab online no prescription does skelaxin show up in drug test zithromax 1 gram safe for pregnancy floxing research pp documented in neoplasia tec one drop deodorizer ingredients in aleve cepacol extra strength ingredients in benadryl telmisartan manufacturers in hyderabad dexamethasone use in premature babies sertraline 50 mg vs 100mg took 6 cialis in one night do they sell lamisil in australia progesterone production in women tnc ecoregions of united states atorvastatin generic recall asaduddin owaisi in aap ki adalat hdl effectiveness safety baclofen what price is seroquel 50 milligram dermodrin sale beipackzettel citalopram mucinex d inactive ingredients in allegra errin norethindrone 0 35 mg caffeine maxalt lingua 10 mg packungsgröße altace protein in urine natrium diclofenac sale p recipe aricept 10 mg filmomhulde doxycycline and calcium level in blood how much does atarax cost prednisone sales no rx cl salv table in gabapentin buy cheap mega generic isotretinoin accutane chloramphenicol resistance in the typhoid bacillus vardenafil 2 5 mg viagra sales representative acai juice best se comprar cytotec farmacia fenofibrate 145 mg secalip 145 micardis chemist warehouse hydroxyzine 25 mg for grover disease effects of viagra used twice in a row fluoxetine 30 mg side effects buy finpecia india propecia buy buspar no prescription visa sildenafil 50 mg marfan disease buspar panic disorder side effects of ranitidine tablets 150 mg cost of metformin at rite aid tadalafil for women review t where can i buy kamagra in new zealand voltaren resinat in der schwangerschaft luna bar chocolate chunk ingredients in benadryl what is overdose of ibuprofen mg best time of day to give baby nexium clindamycin safety data sheet gi side effects of accutane in teenagers viagra online with palpay true zocor generic name cazuri de coruptie celebrex in romania la viagra generika in england kaufen hydroxyzine pamoate 25 mg what is it for mesacol 400 mg posologia bactrim cephalexin 500 mg capsule for fish price of lisinopril tablets n ai meritat generic lipitor buy isotretinoin pill dimenhydrinate 50 mg dosis machine best time of day flonase risperdal consta 37 5 mg injection for osteoporosis ponstel meledak in english buy kamagra canada no prescription buy estrace tqeovertoz allergies in dogs treatment benadryl cream role of erythromycin in uti toprol xl 25 mg tablet sale bisul amoxicillin 500 mg ofloxacin tablets 400 mg will generic crestor available us dosage for clindamycin 150 mg remedio miosan generico do viagra 28 black acai ingredients in meth over the counter version of betamethasone ramipril hm 1 mg cetirizine in spanish tritace mite 1 25 mg tegretol de 400 mg maxpro 20 mg prednisone can i take benadryl in my second trimester strong viagra online guaranteed cheapest cialis buying viagra without perscription metronidazole 500 mg drug interactions metronidazole 200 mg tabletin yan etkileri estrace 2 mg sublingual salivary diprolene 0 055 pomade reviews comprar viagra bogota order nexium rowcmoadreders diana air guns for sale in uk zithromax order plavix from india citalopram hydrobromide 20 mg recreational activities amoxicillin clav curam 625 mg cataflam otc market cost of a depo provera shot information best for monopril ed oto ease ingredients in aleve generic drug warnings for zoloft petsafe 3 volt lithium battery module rfa 188 revia tem generico de cialis alfuzosin price philippines side effects dicyclomine 10 mg viagra generika g?nstig bestellen side effects of fosamax generic information carbamazepine over counter phenergan with codeine pills canada nadrealna televizija epizoda 6 celadrin generic brand viagra online buy generic viagra and generic sildenafil citrate lisinopril 10 mg costs lawyers handling benicar suits in delaware safe drink strattera paraffinum perliquidum nebenwirkungen diclofenac cardura 2 mg 20 tb computer clomid 50 mg comprar montelukast sodium monograph in mexican pharmacies oral diflucan powder buy online cialis 20mg prices cvs cymbalta in teenagers best time take arava fluoxetine 20 mg presentaciones probenecid price philippines nokia kerydin generic cymbalta does ibuprofen 800 mg raise blood pressure como tomar orlistat 80 mg progesterone costco jobs first active ingredient in zantac donde comprar misoprostol df generic viagra visa gift card is allopurinol safe during pregnancy dapoxetine brands in pakistan face diltiazem er generic equivalent serevent inhaler buy and sell para se usa inderal celebrex online australia abilify generic from canada diclofenac sodium over the counter usa cost of keppra with insurance quetros 25 mg promethazine alendronate sodium compared to actonel generic triamcinolone acetonide p f 80 mgml lescol 20 mg bivirkninger av prednisolone amoxicillin trihydrate capsules ip 500 mg to grams propecia reviews results lipitor drug price in india how much acetaminophen is in 500 mg of hydrocodone cialis sans ordonnance canada 20 mg methotrexate equivalent alcohol lithium ionen akku brand propranolol nombre generico definicion can i cut a 5 mg. cialis trental over the counter neurontin 300 mg capsule p d actoplus met 15mg 850 mg tablets entwine creme jelle styler ingredients in aleve atrovent generic name acai berry diet pills in india cost of lamisil for 6 months prednisone safe dogs dexamethasone 0 5 mg 5ml elixir cialis 20mg tablets uk flomax price at walmart 60 mg prednisone for 3 weeks no taper voltaren 75 mg iv rosuvastatin market cost of generic plavix vs coumadin adata asp550ss3 120 mg cymbalta manmath ras ingredients in aleve nootropil 800 mg pretzel imipramine in pakistan ranitidine 300 mg efectos secundarios cialis generico quando in commercio

To: IAHF List
Subject: Article By Dr.Gaby: Safe Upper Limits for Nutritional Supplements: One Giant Step BACKWARD
Date: 27 Jan 2004 21:57:13 -0000

IAHF List: Alan Gaby, MD just sent me his article (see below) which was just published in the Special Issue of the Journal of Orthomolecular Medicine on the Safety and Efficacy of Vitamins. The footnotes are not included, if you require the footnotes, please order a copy of the original from JOM at http://www.orthomed.org/jom/jom.htm

I just sent this article to Dr.Antoinette Booyzen, South African Codex Delegate who as things currently stand, appears to be convinced that CRN's views on "Safe Upper Limits" are "scientific". This article refutes any such conclusion. Please forward it to your countries delegate to the UN Codex Alimentarius Commission's Committee on Nutrition and Food for Special Dietary Uses.

There is a very real danger that unless enough vitamin consumers world wide lobby against it, a grossly unscientific vitamin standard could be rushed through to completion at the next Codex meeting in November in Bonn, Germany.

I am especially concerned that pharma dominated controlled opposition groups CRN and IADSA have announced their intention to hold a political summit meeting two days before the next Codex meeting. Unless enough consumers world wide get behind ANH's legal and lobbying efforts, we won't be able to stop the pharmaceutical takeover of the natural products industry. (The CRN meeting is October 24- 27th, the CRN/IADSA Political Summit to screw the dietary supplement industry is being held October 28-29th, and the Codex meeting is the following monday, 2 days later, starting November 1st......)

Want more help in connecting the dots? Read the Cover story interview Greg Ciola did with me in the Dec/Jan issue of The Health Crusader Magazine at http://www.thehealthcrusader.com/pgs/article-0104-ban.shtml Please forward this like wildfire throughout your up and downlines if you are a network marketing distributor for any CRN member company: Mannatech, Shaklee, Herbalife, GNLD, NuSkin.

These companies have been lied to by CRN in a press release on CRN's website which proclaims that a "victory" has been won at Codex due to RDA's being scrapped in favor of so called "Safe Upper Levels" (allegedly based on "science") but Gaby's article (see below) EXPLODES that contention....

I am blown away by the naivete of such people as Sam Caster at Mannatech who has been flattered by CRN's making him a Board Member so he thinks John Hathcock at CRN is "his friend". Sam better wake up, because Hathcock used to work at FDA and might as well STILL be working at FDA, and he's NOT our friend, Gaby's article EXPLODES any contention that we can trust Hathcock's so called "scientific" risk assessment methodology, which was misextrapolated from toxicological risk assessment methodology originally intended for the evaluation of toxic pharmaceutical DRUGS and which they're MISAPPLYING to safe vitamins.

Never forget that CRN is dominated by Wyeth, Monsanto, Bayer, BASF, and Pfizer....

"Safe Upper Limits" for nutritional supplements: one giant step backward

by Alan R. Gaby, M.D.

In May, 2003, the "Expert Group on Vitamins and Minerals" (EVM), an advisory group originally commissioned in 1988 by the then Ministry of Agriculture Fisheries and Food, and subsequently reporting to the Food Standards Agency in England, published a report that set "Safe Upper Limits" (SULs) for the doses of most vitamin and mineral supplements. The establishment of SULs was based on a review of clinical and epidemiological evidence, as well as animal research and in vitro studies. For those nutrients for which the available evidence was judged insufficient to set an SUL, the EVM instead established "Guidance Levels", which were to be considered less reliable than SULs.

This writer's analysis of the EVM report reveals that the dose limits were set inappropriately low for many vitamins and minerals; well below doses which have been used by the public for decades with apparent safety. While the release of this 360-page document would be of little import, were it to be used solely as a manifesto for the pathologically risk-averse, preliminary indications are that it could be used very actively to support the arguments of those who are seeking to ban the over-the-counter sale of many currently available nutritional supplements. If the report is used that way, then the public health could be jeopardized.

On May 30, 2002, the European Union adopted Directive 2002/46/EC, which established a framework for setting maximum limits for vitamins and minerals in food supplements. The EVM report is seen by the UK government as the basis for its negotiating position in the process of setting these pan-European limits.

The apparent anti-nutritional-supplement, anti-self-care bias that permeated the process of setting safety limits is evident both in the way in which the SUL was defined and in the fact that the benefits of nutritional supplements were purposely ignored. The SUL was defined as the maximum dose of a particular nutrient "that potentially susceptible individuals could take daily on a life-long basis, without medical supervision in reasonable safety." In other words, it is the highest dose that is unlikely to cause anyone any harm, ever, under any circumstance. Furthermore, the EVM was specifically instructed not to consider the benefits of any of the nutrients, and not to engage in risk/benefit analysis.

There is little or no precedent in free societies for restricting access to products or activities to levels that are completely risk-free. Aspirin causes intestinal bleeding, water makes people drown, driving a car causes accidents, and free speech may offend the exquisitely offendable. Politicians and bureaucrats do not seek to ban aspirin or water or driving or free speech, because their benefits outweigh their risks. For vitamins and minerals, however, some authorities seem to believe that unique safety criteria are needed.

Moreover, the government's instructions to disregard the many documented benefits of nutritional supplements introduced a serious bias into the evaluation process. As the EVM acknowledged, determining safety limits involves an enormous degree of uncertainty and a fairly wide range of possible outcomes. The committee might have established higher safety limits than it did, had it been told to weigh benefits against risks. The government's instructions appeared to be an implicit directive to err on the side of excluding doses that are being used to prevent or treat disease. And that is what the EVM did, often by making questionable interpretations of the data, and doing so in what appears to have been an arbitrary and inconsistent manner.

Riboflavin Guidance Level

A typical example of the EVM's dubious approach to establishing safety limits is its evaluation of riboflavin. The committee acknowledged that no toxic effects have been reported in animals given an acute oral dose of 10,000 mg/kg of body weight, or after long-term ingestion of 25 mg/kg/day (equivalent to 1,750 mg/day for a 70-kg human). Moreover, in a study of 28 patients taking riboflavin for migraine prophylaxis, a dose of 400 mg/day for 3 months did not cause any adverse effects. Despite a complete absence of side effects at any dose in either humans or animals, the EVM set the Guidance Level for riboflavin at 40 mg/day. That level was established by dividing the 400 mg/day used in the migraine study by an "uncertainty factor" of 10, to allow for variability in the susceptibility of human beings to adverse effects.

A more appropriate conclusion regarding riboflavin would have been that no adverse effects have been observed at any dose, and that there is no basis at this time for establishing an upper limit. If the EVM's recommendation is used to limit the potency of riboflavin tablets to 40 mg, then migraine sufferers will have to take 10 pills per day, in order to prevent migraine recurrences.

Vitamin B6 Safe Upper Limit

Similar reasoning led to an SUL of 10 mg/day for vitamin B6, even though this vitamin has been used with apparent safety, usually in doses of 50 to 200 mg/day, to treat carpal tunnel syndrome, premenstrual syndrome, asthma, and other common problems. The SUL for vitamin B6 was derived from an animal study, in which a dose of 50 mg/kg of body weight/day (equivalent to 3,000 mg/day for a 60-kg person) resulted in neurotoxicity. The EVM reduced that dose progressively by invoking three separate "uncertainty factors:" 1) by a factor of 3, to extrapolate from the lowest-observed-adverse-effect-level (LOAEL) to a no-observed-adverse-effect-level (NOAEL); 2) by an additional factor of 10, to account for presumed inter-species differences; and 3) by a further factor of 10 to account for inter-individual variation in humans. Thus, the neurotoxic dose in animals was reduced by a factor of 300, to a level that excludes the widely used 50- and 100-mg tablets.

The decision to base the SUL for vitamin B6 on animal data (modified by a massive "uncertainty factor") was arbitrary, considering that toxicology data are available for humans. A sensory neuropathy has been reported in some individuals taking large doses of vitamin B6. Most people who suffered this adverse effect were taking 2,000 mg/day or more of pyridoxine, although some were taking only 500 mg/day. There is a single case report of a neuropathy occurring in a person taking 200 mg/day of pyridoxine, but the reliability of that case report is unclear. The individual in question was never examined, but was merely interviewed by telephone after responding to a local television report that publicized pyridoxine-induced neuropathy.

Because pyridoxine neurotoxicity has been known to the medical profession for 20 years, and because vitamin B6 is being taken by millions of people, it is reasonable to assume that neurotoxicity at doses below 200 mg/day would have been reported by now, if it does occur at those doses. The fact that no such reports have appeared strongly suggests that vitamin B6 does not damage the nervous system when taken at doses below 200 mg/day. As the EVM did with other nutrients for which a LOAEL is known for humans, it could have divided the vitamin B6 LOAEL (200 mg/day) by 3 to obtain an SUL of 66.7 mg/day. Had the committee been allowed to evaluate both the benefits and risks of vitamin B6, it probably would have established the SUL at that level, rather than the 10 mg/day it arrived at through serial decimation of the animal data.

Manganese Guidance Level

Chronic inhalation of high concentrations of airborne manganese, as might be encountered in mines or steel mills, has been reported to cause a neuropsychiatric syndrome that resembles Parkinson's disease. In contrast, manganese is considered one of the least toxic trace minerals when ingested orally, and reports of human toxicity from oral ingestion are "essentially nonexistent." The neurotoxicity that occurs in miners and industrial workers may result from a combination of high concentrations of manganese in the air and, possibly, direct entry of nasally inhaled manganese into the brain (bypassing the blood-brain barrier).

In establishing a Guidance Level for manganese, the EVM cited a study by Kondakis et al, in which people exposed to high concentrations of manganese in their drinking water (1.8-2.3 mg/L) had more signs and symptoms of subtle neurological dysfunction than did a control group whose drinking water contained less manganese. The committee acknowledged that another epidemiological study by Vieregge et al showed no adverse effects among individuals whose drinking water contained up to 2.1 mg/L of manganese. The EVM hypothesized that these studies may not really be contradictory, since the subjects in the Kondakis study were, on average, 10 years older than were those in the Vieregge study, and increasing age might theoretically render people more susceptible to manganese toxicity. Based on the results of these two studies, the EVM established a Guidance Level for supplemental manganese of 4 mg/day for the general population and 0.5 mg/day for elderly individuals.

There are serious problems with the EVM's analysis of the manganese research. First, the committee overlooked that fact that in the Kondakis study the people in the high-manganese group were older than were those in the control group (mean age, 67.6 vs. 65.6 years). Many of the neurological symptoms that were investigated in this study are nonspecific and presumably age related, including fatigue, muscle pain, irritability, insomnia, sleepiness, decreased libido, depression, slowness in rising from a chair, and memory disturbances. The fact that the older people had more symptoms than did the younger people is not surprising, and may have been totally unrelated to the manganese content of their drinking water.

Second, the EVM broke its own rules regarding the use of uncertainty factors, presumably to avoid being faced with an embarrassingly low Guidance Level for the general population. In setting the level at 4 mg/day, the committee stated: "No uncertainty factor is required as the NOAEL [obtained from the Vieregge study] is based on a large epidemiological study." As a point of information, the Nurses' Health Study was a large epidemiological study, enrolling more than 85,000 participants. The Beaver Dam Eye Study was a medium-sized epidemiological study, enrolling more than 3,000 participants. In contrast, in the Vieregge study, there were only 41 subjects in the high-manganese group, making it a very small epidemiological study. In its evaluation of the biotin, riboflavin, and pantothenic acid research, the EVM reduced the NOAEL by an uncertainty factor of 10, in part because only small numbers of subjects had been studied. Considering that more subjects were evaluated in the pantothenic acid research (n = 94) than in the Vieregge study (n = 41), it would seem appropriate also to use an uncertainty factor the for manganese data. Applying an uncertainty factor of 10 to the Vieregge study would have produced an absurdly low Guidance Level of 0.4 mg/day for supplemental manganese, which is well below the amount present in a typical diet (approximately 4 mg/day) and which can be obtained by drinking several sips of tea. Parenthetically, in a study of 47,351 male health professionals, drinking large amounts of tea (a major dietary source of manganese) was associated with a reduced risk of Parkinson's disease, not an increased risk. In changing its methodology to avoid reaching an indefensible conclusion, the EVM revealed the arbitrary and inconsistent nature of its evaluation process.

Niacin (nicotinic acid) Guidance Level

Large doses of niacin (such as 3,000 mg/day) can cause hepatotoxicity and other significant side effects. The EVM focused its evaluation, however, on the niacin-induced skin flush, which occurs at much lower doses. The niacin flush is a sensation of warmth on the skin, often associated with itching, burning, or irritation that occurs after the ingestion of niacin and disappears relatively quickly. It appears to be mediated in part by the release of prostaglandins. The niacin flush is not considered a toxic effect per se, and there is no evidence that it causes any harm. People who do not like the flush are free not to take niacin supplements or products that contain niacin. For those who are unaware that niacin causes a flush, an appropriate warning label on the bottle would provide adequate protection.

Granting, for the sake of argument, that the niacin flush is an adverse effect from which the public should be protected, the EVM's Guidance Level still is illogical. The committee noted that flushing is consistently observed at a dose 50 mg/day, which it established as the LOAEL. That dose was reduced by an uncertainty factor of 3, in order to extrapolate the LOAEL to a NOAEL. Thus, the Guidance Level was set at 17 mg/day, which approximates the RDA for the vitamin. The EVM also noted, however, that flushing has been reported at doses as low as 10 mg, so the true LOAEL is 10 mg/day. Applying the same uncertainty factor of 3 to the true LOAEL would have yielded a Guidance Level of a paltry 3.3 mg/day, which probably is not enough to prevent an anorexic person from developing pellagra. As with manganese, the EVM applied its methodology in an arbitrary and inconsistent manner, so as to avoid being faced with an embarrassing result.

Vitamin C Guidance Level

The EVM concluded that vitamin C does not cause significant adverse effects, although gastrointestinal (GI) side effects may occur with high doses. The committee therefore set a Guidance Level based on a NOAEL for GI side effects. It is true that taking too much vitamin C, just like eating too many apples, may cause abdominal pain or diarrhea. The dose at which vitamin C causes GI side effects varies widely from person to person, but can easily be determined by each individual. Moreover, these side effects can be eliminated by reducing the dose. Most people who take vitamin C supplements know how much they can tolerate; for those who do not, a simple warning on bottles of vitamin C would appear to provide the public all the protection it needs. Considering the many health benefits of vitamin C, attempting to dumb down the dose to a level that will prevent the last stomachache in Europe is not a worthwhile goal. However, as mentioned previously, the EVM was instructed to ignore the benefits of vitamin C.

Granting, for the sake of argument, that there is value in setting a Guidance Level for GI side effects, the EVM did a rather poor job of setting that level. The committee established the LOAEL at 3,000 mg/day, based on a study of a small number of normal volunteers. An uncertainty factor of 3 was used to extrapolate from the LOAEL to a NOAEL, resulting in a Guidance Level of 1,000 mg/day. However, anyone practicing nutritional medicine knows that some patients experience abdominal pain or diarrhea at vitamin C doses of 1,000 mg/day or less, and the EVM did acknowledge that GI side effects have been reported at doses of 1,000 mg. It is disingenuous to set a NOAEL and then to concede that effects do occur at the no-effect level. To be consistent with the methodology it used for other nutrients, the committee should have set the LOAEL at 1,000 mg/day, and reduced it by a factor of 3 to arrive at a NOAEL of 333 mg/day. The EVM was no doubt aware of the credibility problems it would have faced, had it suggested that half the world is currently overdosing on vitamin C. To resolve its dilemma, the committee used a scientifically unjustifiable route to arrive at a seemingly politically expedient outcome.


These and other examples from the report demonstrate that the EVM applied its methodology in an arbitrary and inconsistent manner, in arriving at "safety" recommendations that are excessively and inappropriately restrictive. While the directive to evaluate only the risks, and to ignore the benefits, of nutritional supplements created a rigged game, the members of the EVM appeared to be willing participants in that game.

If the EVM report is used to relegate currently available nutritional supplements to prescription-only status, then millions of people would be harmed, and very few would benefit. It would be of little consolation that the higher doses of vitamins and minerals could still be obtained with a doctor's prescription, because most doctors know less about nutrition than many of their patients do. Moreover, the overburdened health-care system is in no position to take on the job of gatekeeper of the vitamin cabinet; nor is there any need for it to do so.

Ironically, as flawed as the EVM report is, its recommendations may ultimately prove to be "as good as it gets" in Europe. Other European countries are recommending that maximum permitted levels be directly linked to multiples of the RDA, which could result in limits for some nutrients being set substantially lower than those suggested in the EVM report.

While some nutritional supplements can cause adverse effects in certain clinical situations or at certain doses, appropriate warning labels on vitamin and mineral products would provide ample protection against most of those risks.

Note: Reprinted with permission from the Journal of Orthomolecular Medicine (in press), as part of a special issue devoted to clearing up the confusion about the toxicity of vitamins.

For Health Freedom,
John C. Hammell, President
International Advocates for Health Freedom
556 Boundary Bay Road
Point Roberts, WA 98281-8702 USA
800-333-2553 N.America
360-945-0352 World